Friday, August 23, 2013

The Butler

You can’t go full retard and expect to win an Oscar! I’m paraphrasing Tropic Thunder there a bit, but honestly they were on to something in that silly little movie, there really is a simple formula that exists in Hollywood if you want to get nominated for an Academy Award. This is especially true if you’re a black actor and more specifically a black woman. You either get physically and verbally abused your entire life while possibly getting AIDS like Whoopi Goldberg (Color Purple) and Gabourey Sidibe (Precious), let some dirty old man bang you sideways in the longest sex scene ever while you beg for it like Halle Berry (Monster’s Ball), or be a maid for white people like…well, every black woman ever who’s been cast this role. Speaking of Billy Bob Thorton, he really should’ve killed himself after Monster’s Ball; it was all downhill for him after that. He was dating Angelina Jolie in her hottest and craziest time and he then got paid to grope and make out with a naked Halle Berry for days! That bastard!

Anyway, Hattie McDaniel was the first to win back in a day when 90% of Texas still thought slavery was legal. Taraji P. Henson was nominated for taking care of an old Brad Pitt and everyone in The Help was nominated for everything they did that year (including commercials) because of their roles in that movie.

So Forest Whitaker decides that it’s his turn to get an easy nomination, and why not, it worked for Morgan Freeman in Driving Miss Daisy didn’t it? He plays the role of Cecil Gaines, a man who moved his way up from being a child slave working in the fields, to becoming a butler in The White House for 5 different Presidents. As they tell his story they also tell the story of his boy Louis Gaines (David Oyelowo) and his personal fight against social inequality and prejudice against skin color. One is unknowingly changing stereotypes of black men and their work ethic by taking pride in their work and doing so with class and dignity, while the other is taking action to change America’s culture by joining the Freedom Fighters,  Martin Luther King’s movement, the Black Panthers (in a negative response to Dr King’s assassination) and eventually Congress.

Along the way however, not only do they both face challenges in their own occupations but they also fight with one another constantly. Louis is ashamed of his father’s profession and Cecil cannot understand why his son continues to defy him and consistently puts his life in danger. And I haven’t even gotten to the fact that Cecil’s wife now resents his job and the fact that it takes away time that he can spend with her.

The acting in this movie is solid all the way around. Whitaker kills it as the proud black man that has worked his way up so that his family doesn’t have to go through what he did. But at the same time he knows exactly how he has to act around the White House to not cause any waves. This at times can be unbelievably frustrating for the viewer because it’s like having access to Superman but given your situation, all you can really do is sit there and admire his cape. If Whitaker is nominated, it would definitely be well deserved. Oprah also deserves a nomination, and it’s not just because she will draw 100 million women to the movie simply because she’s in it. Based off of what she did in this movie and her unbelievable performance in The Color Purple, she really could’ve been the black Meryl Streep. But as it turns out she’s too busy living out her Pinky and the Brain fantasy of ruling the world, which is getting closer to becoming a reality each day. The only parts that weren’t believable were when she had to kiss a man in a scene. It was seriously like watching a straight male actor kiss another man on camera; yes they are doing it but you can tell that they want to get it over with as quickly as possible.

Cuba Gooding Jr is probably the most memorable supporting actor in the film. I know women will disagree with me because Lenny Kravitz is in it but Cuba was so excited to be a part of a real film again that he actually steps up and owns his character. It helps that he is basically playing a role that encapsulates how the world views him now, but Marky Mark did the same thing in The Departed and it got him an Oscar nomination, so why couldn't it work for Cuba?  Here’s to hoping that playing the role of a joke cracking butler lands him in the sequel to the overlooked Hopkins vehicle, Instinct. “Splendad!!!” As my buddy Don says “Greatness is rarely recognized in its time”. He just happened to be talking about Nicolas Cage at the time.


If you can overlook some of the silly casting choices they made for a few of the presidents, you will find yourself immersed in a film that gives you a realistic view of racism, heartache, and even hope. It doesn’t matter how many times you see the horrific acts that took place during the Civil Rights movement or the results of Vietnam, you cant help but be moved in some way. I hate to gloss over the fact that Mariah Carey actually looked hot in this movie, David Banner pops in for a bit, and Oyelowo was on point as Cecil's son, but I can only write so much.I rate this movie as FRESH and suggest that you pop in.

1 comment: